The short answer is no. If your car is damaged in Washington, you decide which shop repairs it. Your insurance company can recommend shops, but it can’t require you to use one of them. That is true when your own insurer is paying and when the other driver’s insurer is paying.
We explain this at our counter in Pasco almost every week, usually to someone who has just been handed a list of shops and told it will be “easier” to pick from it.
What a “preferred” or “network” shop is
Most large insurers run direct repair programs. A shop in the program signs a contract with the insurer. In exchange for a steady stream of claims, the shop agrees to the insurer’s terms on things like labor rates, parts and repair procedures.
There is nothing illegal about that, and plenty of network shops do good work. But it helps to understand the relationship. The network shop has two customers. One is you, and the other is the insurance company that sends it work.
An independent shop has one customer. Barajas Auto Body has never signed an insurance contract. We still work with every insurance company, every day. The difference is who we answer to when there is a decision to make about your car.
What the adjuster might say
When you say you would like to use your own shop, you may hear some version of the following.
- “We can’t guarantee the work if you go outside our network.” The repair is guaranteed by the shop that does it. Our repair work and paint carry a lifetime warranty for as long as you own the vehicle.
- “It will take longer.” The claim follows the same steps at any shop, which are the estimate, the approval, the repair and a supplement if hidden damage is found.
- “You may have to pay the difference.” Your insurer owes what it reasonably costs to repair the vehicle properly. If there is a disagreement about a line on the estimate, we work it out with the adjuster directly, with photos.
None of these change the basic rule. The choice is yours.
How to tell your insurer you chose your own shop
- Open the claim if you haven’t yet. If you’re not sure how, call us first and we’ll walk you through it.
- Tell them plainly. Say “I’m having my vehicle repaired at Barajas Auto Body, 700 W Columbia St in Pasco.”
- Give us the claim number. We send the estimate and photos to your adjuster.
- Let us handle the back and forth. If we find hidden damage once the car is apart, we document it and get it approved before we repair it.
- Pay your deductible at pickup. The insurer pays us the rest.
What if the other driver was at fault?
It works the same way. You can file with the other driver’s insurer or with your own, and either way the shop is your choice. If you file with your own company, you pay your deductible and your insurer may recover it for you from the other company.
Where to check the rules
Washington’s Office of the Insurance Commissioner publishes consumer guidance on auto claims and takes complaints if you believe an insurer is steering you unfairly. It’s worth a look if you’re getting pushback.
The bottom line
Pick the shop you trust, tell your insurer, and let the shop do the paperwork. If you’re in Pasco, Kennewick or Richland and want a second opinion on an estimate, text us photos and we’ll take a look at no charge.